As to what happened in more detail, read my statement about this and the related case. The Deseret News reported about below case.

3RD DISTRICT COURT - SALT LAKE

SALT LAKE COUNTY, STATE OF UTAH

DIVISION OF MENTAL HEALTH vs. UTAH STATE RECORDS COMMITTEE

CASE NUMBER 010907201 Miscellaneous

CURRENT ASSIGNED JUDGE

J DENNIS FREDERICK

PARTIES

Plaintiff - DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES

Plaintiff - DIVISION OF MENTAL HEALTH

Defendant - UTAH STATE RECORDS COMMITTEE

Represented by: MARK E BURNS

ACCOUNT SUMMARY

CASE NOTE

PROCEEDINGS

08-15-01 Filed: Complaint - karries

08-21-01 Judge FREDERICK assigned. karries 08-29-01

Filed: Amended Complaint, heaths 08-29-01

Filed: Summons, heaths

08-29-01 Filed: Acceptance of Service of Process, heaths

"

09-11-01 Filed: Motion by Barbara Schwarz to order Ptf. and Dft. of this

case to provide me with service copy of what they file in this case:

and Motion by B. Schwarz to this court to provide me with

any order this court renders in this case & motion to Dis, heaths

09-21-01 Filed: Plaintiff's Memorandum Opposing Schwarz's Motion to

Dismiss, heaths

09-26-01 Filed: Answer, heaths

UTAH STATE RECORDS COMMITTEE

10-02-01 Filed: Notice to Submit for Decision, heaths

10-02-01 Filed: Response Motion by Barbara Schwarz to Plaintiff's Memo

to oppose my motion to dismiss, renewed request to dismiss this

case or alternatively to hear me, heaths

10-04-01 Filed: M/E Ruling - Movant's Motion to Dismiss, etc is denied

for the reasons specified in the memorandum in opposition.

Counsel for plaintiff to prepare the order,cindyb

11-13-01 Filed order: Order (m/e ruling 10/4/01),cindyb, Judge jfrederi

Printed: 07/23/03 15:22:46 Page 1

CASE NUMBER 010907201 Miscellaneous

Signed November 13, 2001,

11-27-01 Filed: Notice of Appeal, larieh

11-27-01 Filed: Affidavit of Impecuniosity, larieh 11-27-01,

Note: Forwarded Cert/Copies of Notice of Appeal, Affidavit of

Impecuniosity to Court of Appeals, sophieo

12-05-01 Filed: Letter from Court of Appeals (Noa received, Court of

Appeals No. 20010942-ca) sophieo

02-12-02 Filed: Stipulation, heaths 02-12-02 Filed order: Order Allowing Intervention of Barbara Schwarz as a defendant, heaths, Judge jfrederi

Signed February 12, 2002

03-05-02 Filed: Response Motion by Barbara Schwarz to Complaint by

Plaintiff and to Order by Judge Frederick Allowing Intervention

of Barbara Schwarz as defendant, heaths

03-05-02 Filed: Affidavit, heaths

05-01-02 Filed: Remittitur Received - Coa#20010942-ca - Appeal Dismissed

- Record Received: File-1, u-npaginated, sophieo

01-16-03 Filed: Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings, heaths

01-16-03 Filed: Defendant's Memorandum in Support of Motion for Judgment

on the Pleadings, heaths

01-21-03 Filed: Objection by Barbara Schwarz to Footnote on Page 5 of

Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings, heaths

01-22-03 Filed: Defendant's Amended Memorandum in Support of Motion for

Judgment on the Pleadings, heaths

01-28-03 Filed: Amended Objection to Defendant's Motion for Judgment on

the Pleadings, heaths

02-04-03 Filed: Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings, heaths

02-04-03 Filed: Memorandum Supporting Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on

the Pleadings and in Opposition to Defendant Utah State Records Committee's Motin for Judgment on the Pleadings, heaths

02-10-03 Filed: Response by Barbara Schwarz to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings and to Memo Supporting Plaintiff's Motion and in Opposition to Defendant Utah State Records Committee's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings, heaths

02-25-03 Filed: Notice to Submit for Decision (Pltf's Motion for

Judgment on the Pleadings),cindyb

02-26-03 Filed: M/E Ruling - Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment on the

Pleadings is granted for the reasons specified in the supporting memorandum. Counsel for movant to prepare the order.." and judgment, cindyb

i 03-06-03 Filed: Objection to Proposed Order and Judgment by Plaintiff, rhondam

03-11-03 Filed order: Judgment and Order (pltf's motion for judgment on I pleadings is granted, deft Records Committee's motion for

judgment on pleadings is denied) ,cindyb, Judge jfrederi Signed March 11, 2003

03-11-03 Case Disposition is Judgment cindyb; Disposition Judge is J DENNIS FREDERICK, cindyb

Printed: 07/23/03 15:22:46 Page 2

CASE NUMBER 010907201 Miscellaneous

03-31-03 Filed: Affidavit of Impecuniosity, rhondam

03-31-03 Filed: Notice of Appeal,rhondam

04-04-03 Note: Cert. copies of Notice of Appeal & Affidavit of Impecuniosity forwarded to Court of Appeals, kathys

04-23-03 Filed: Letter from Supreme Court - Noa received, Supreme Court

No. 20030324-sc sophieo

04-24-03 Filed: Certificate that Transcript is not Required, wesleyo

05~01-03 Note: Cert. copy of Certificate that No Transcript is Required

forwarded to Supreme Court, kathys

05-28-03 Note: Indexed: Cert/Copy of Index sent to Supreme Court -

S.C.#20030324-sc, sophieo

06-11-03 Filed: Letter from Supreme Court - Order -' Case transferred to

Court of Appeals, sophieo

06-17-03 Filed: Letter from Court of Appeals - Case assigned to Court of

Appeals - Coa#20030324-ca, sophieo

Printed: 07/23/03 15:22:46 Page 3 (last)

BELOW IS ALSO THE DOCKET SHEET OF THE UTAH COURT OF APPEALS ON THE APPEAL CASE

Utah Court of Appeals 02/28/2002

Docket Event Listing

Schwarz v. Division Of Mental Health

Docket No: 20010942 Docket Date: 11/27/2001 App. Type: Civil Appeal

Agency: THIRD DISTRICT, SALT LAKE Case: 010907201

Status: Dismissal Pending

Barbara Schwarz - Appellant Pro Se

DHS, Division of Mental Health - Appellee

JOEL L. FERRE ( ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL)

Utah State Records Committee - Appellee

MARK E. BURNS ( ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL)

01 11/27/2001 Notice of Appeal Filed, Pro Se packet to appellant today.

02 11/27/2001 Affidavit of Impecuniosity fil (sic) Appellant's

03 12/14/2001 Docketing Statement Filed

04 12/19/2001 Called for Record

Sent memo asking for record, asis (sic) let CS know when its here

05 12/21/2001 Misc. Letter

A letter from the appellant regaring the case heading and the appellee's not having the right attorney. 1 OF 2

06 12/21/2001 Transcript Not Required

Appellant's does not require transcrtps. (sic) 2 of 2

07 12/26/2001 Record Filed - Pursuant to R.1

1 pldg

08 12/28/2001 Motion-Appellee-Summary Dispos, appellee's motion for sumamry disposition, CS

09 12/28/2001 Memorandum of Points & Authori,

Appellee's memorandum in supporting appellee's motion for sumamry (sic)

disposition. CS

10 12/31/2001 Sua Sponte Motion for Summary Dispos,

This appeal is being considered for summary dismissal in the basis that this court lacks jurisdiction because the order from which Ms. Schwarz appeals is not a final appealable order. The memorandum should be filed on Janaury 22, 2002, PTG.

11 01/02/2002 Response to Motion for Summary, CS

Appellant's response motion to appellee's motion and memo for summary disposition

12 01/24/2002 Response to Motion for Summary

Appellee's Utah State Records Committee's response to motion for summary disposition.

1302/07/2002 Summary Disposition

PER CURIAM, We dismiss the appeal. The dismisal is without prejudice to filing a timely appeal once a final order is enteres, because we do not have jurudiction, we do not address the additional issiea (sic) raised in appellee's motion.

14 02/12/2002 Petition for Rehearing Denied 02/20/2002, Appellant's motion for rehearing, JMB

15 02/20/2002 Petition for Rehearing, Denied,

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that intervenor/appellant's petition for rehearing is hereby denied, JMB

16 12/31/2099 Rehearing Petition Due, Due (sic) 02/25/2002

17 12/31/2099 Review of Case Due, Due (sic) 01/25/2002

18 12/31/2099 Remittitur Oue - COA Due 04/0B/2002

The docket sheets of the courts are as unprofessional as the rulings of the judges. Note that judge Frederick allowed me to "intervene" but did not hear me, which was of course an ourrageous denial of my rights, so was his ruling that people being "referred" for mental health treatments, may not know who did that to them.

Anyway, appeal case number 20030324-CA, the second appeal from this case is still pending before the Utah Court of Appeals. It is fully briefed.

Click also on below link, about another judge, even a New Jersey State Supreme Court judge, Peter Verniero, who announced to step down from the bench after a racial profiling controversy. Him stepping back would avoid any debate that the question of reappointment might have engendered.

http://nj.com/newsflash/jersey/index.ssf?/base-4/106493394214061.xml

If this is not an admission of guilt, bad conscience and non-confront, what is it then?

Barbara Schwarz

Go Back