olomus asked this question on 3/22/2000:

I understand why the legal system feels it necessary to place people in jail for certain "crimes". However, I also believe there should be programs available to help rehabilitate them, educate them, and prepare them for "changing their ways".

My husband is currently service a jail sentance for a DWI. There are no AA meetings, no alcohol/drug counseling (1-on-1 or group), no church services, no education classes for drug and/or alcohol abuse, at this jail. He merely has to play a waiting game until his sentance is over and will be no more the wiser for "paying his dues to society" upon his release.

Why doesn't the justice system "see" that this method isn't rehabilitating (educating or helping) these people who (and most of them in jail are) in for alcohol/drug abuse situations? Is there anything in the works to change this?

d_ottr gave this response on 3/25/2000:

Incarceration is an antiquated method of deterrance in that the citizenry is supposed to fear the incarceration, and therefore avoid criminal conduct. In today's society, incarceration is such commonplace activity, it is no longer a matter of "if," to some it is a matter of "when." This is especially true with DUI/DWI. Intermediate penalties, such as Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition (ARD) and House Arrest have met with some success in Pennsylvania, however the purpose of the programs is to ensure more room at the jail for other criminals. With the high cost of lodging someone in jail (around $45 per person per day) it is sometimes cost prohibitive to provide all the services you mention. That is not to the benefit of the pirsoner, though.

If the prisoner really wants help, instead of religous services he could read his Bible; Other literature and information could be obtained on the other subjects you mention. Incarceration should be a time of deep introspection. There is nothing but time on his hands right at that moment, so why not use to to better himself? Too many are in jail to work out, posture themselves for post-release life on the streets, and educating themselves on how NOT to get caught the next time. If more used their down time for more constructive purposes, there would certainly be a decline in recidivism (repeat offenders).

After his release, there are no doubt support groups for him if he really wants to get well. NA, AA, etc. can help, but while he's "down," he should personally resolve himself to making his life better when he gets outside.

The average rating for this answer is 4.

olomus rated this answer a 4.

Thank you.